A group of Aston Villa players, including Benteke, Gabriel Agbonlahor, Gary Gardner and Nathan Baker got together to find out. The group played some FIFA 14 on Xbox One to settle the debate.
Enjoy the video from the event and enjoy some behind-the-scene images.
Villa fans can download an exclusive Aston Villa FIFA 14 cover for Xbox 360, PlayStation 3 and your mobile device.
FIFA 14 is now available everywhere. Pick up your copy today.